So, if government and its agents (law enforcement) have no legal duty to protect; they cannot be held liable for failing to protect because there is no legal duty to protect in the first place, Why in God's name would they put "Protect & Serve" on the sides of their patrol cars?
Consider the use of the Fairy Tale: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairy_Tales
Consider the use of Guided Imagery:
http://www.academyforguidedimagery.com/whatisguidedimagery/index.html
http://www.synthesiscenter.org/articles/0340.pdf
Answer: Because they could......and it worked.....until now.
Government and its agents (police and district attorneys) have no legal duty to protect; they cannot be held liable for failing to protect. The Problem? They have no legal duty to disclose this. Even worse, there is no evidence that the general population knows of it. See Warren vs. District of Columbia; DeShaney vs. Winnebago County Department of Social Services; Stone vs. N.C. Department of Labor; Castle Rock vs. Gonzales, just to name a few.
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Monday, March 8, 2010
The Public Duty Doctrine.77: Gov't as Fiduciary?
Just left the courthouse. Opened an estate for mom. Gotta pay off who we owe. Mom, a Republican, would have it no other way. Pay as you go, you know. I still can't believe she's gone. I was her son. I am now a fiduciary.
According to Black's Law Dictionary, Fifth Edition, a fiduciary is as follows:
The term is derived from the Roman law, and means (as a noun) a person holding the character of a trustee, or a character analogous to that of a trustee, in respect to the trust and confidence involved in it and the scrupulous good faith and candor which it requires. A person having duty, created by his undertaking, to act primarily for another's benefit in matters connected with such undertaking. As an adjective it means of the nature of a trust; having the characteristics of a trust; analogous to a trust; relating to or founded upon a trust or confidence.
A person or institution who manages money or property for another and who must exercise a standard of care in such management activity imposed by law or contract; e.g. executor of estate, receiver in bankrupty; trustee. A trustee, for example, possesses a fiduciary responsibility to the beneficiaries of the trust to follow the terms of the trust and the requirements of applicable state law. A breach of fiduciary responsibility would make the trustee liable to the beneficiaries for any damage caused by such breach.
The status of being a fiduciary gives rise to certain legal incidents and obligations, including the prohibition against investing the money or property in investments which are speculative or otherwise imprudent.
As per Black's Law Dictionary, definition of Fiduciary bond:
Type of surety bond required by court to be filed by trustees, administrators, executors, guardians, and conservators to insure proper performance of their duties.
As per Black's, definition of Fiduciary capacity:
One is said to act in a 'fiduciary capacity' or to receive money or contract a debt in such capacity when the business which he transacts, or the money or property which he handles, is not his own or for his own benefit, but for the benefit of another person, as to whom he stands in a relation implying and necessitating great confidence and trust on the one part and a high degree of good faith on the other part. The term is not restricted to technical or express trusts, but includes also such offices or relations as those of an attorney at law, a guardian, executor, or broker, a director of a corporation, and a public officer.
Now............. as recent events have proved, it's apparently all about money and power. Our government bailed out the banks/perps, insurance companies, auto companies, initially turned a blind eye to huge bonuses, SEC asleep at the wheel, on and on and on.
So, (as they say in business: "business is business, nothing personal") why not look at local, state, and federal governments as fiduciaries?
The Public Duty Doctrine states that government and its agents (law enforcement) have no legal duty to protect; they cannot be held liable for failure to protect because there was no legal duty to protect in the first place. There is a conspiracy of silence to keep this from public knowledge.
American law enforcement is huge, consume untold amounts of money to operate, and are fiduciaries, of a sort, in the budgeting and managing of our tax dollars.
Do you know how the fed finally got Al Capone? Tax fraud.
Do you know how local, state, and federal governments might eventually be forced to disclose The Public Duty Doctrine, this most vital of information, to the public? Through the Almighty Dollar. Tie mandatory disclosure of The Public Duty Doctrine to annual law enforcement budgets.
According to Black's Law Dictionary, Fifth Edition, a fiduciary is as follows:
The term is derived from the Roman law, and means (as a noun) a person holding the character of a trustee, or a character analogous to that of a trustee, in respect to the trust and confidence involved in it and the scrupulous good faith and candor which it requires. A person having duty, created by his undertaking, to act primarily for another's benefit in matters connected with such undertaking. As an adjective it means of the nature of a trust; having the characteristics of a trust; analogous to a trust; relating to or founded upon a trust or confidence.
A person or institution who manages money or property for another and who must exercise a standard of care in such management activity imposed by law or contract; e.g. executor of estate, receiver in bankrupty; trustee. A trustee, for example, possesses a fiduciary responsibility to the beneficiaries of the trust to follow the terms of the trust and the requirements of applicable state law. A breach of fiduciary responsibility would make the trustee liable to the beneficiaries for any damage caused by such breach.
The status of being a fiduciary gives rise to certain legal incidents and obligations, including the prohibition against investing the money or property in investments which are speculative or otherwise imprudent.
As per Black's Law Dictionary, definition of Fiduciary bond:
Type of surety bond required by court to be filed by trustees, administrators, executors, guardians, and conservators to insure proper performance of their duties.
As per Black's, definition of Fiduciary capacity:
One is said to act in a 'fiduciary capacity' or to receive money or contract a debt in such capacity when the business which he transacts, or the money or property which he handles, is not his own or for his own benefit, but for the benefit of another person, as to whom he stands in a relation implying and necessitating great confidence and trust on the one part and a high degree of good faith on the other part. The term is not restricted to technical or express trusts, but includes also such offices or relations as those of an attorney at law, a guardian, executor, or broker, a director of a corporation, and a public officer.
Now............. as recent events have proved, it's apparently all about money and power. Our government bailed out the banks/perps, insurance companies, auto companies, initially turned a blind eye to huge bonuses, SEC asleep at the wheel, on and on and on.
So, (as they say in business: "business is business, nothing personal") why not look at local, state, and federal governments as fiduciaries?
The Public Duty Doctrine states that government and its agents (law enforcement) have no legal duty to protect; they cannot be held liable for failure to protect because there was no legal duty to protect in the first place. There is a conspiracy of silence to keep this from public knowledge.
American law enforcement is huge, consume untold amounts of money to operate, and are fiduciaries, of a sort, in the budgeting and managing of our tax dollars.
Do you know how the fed finally got Al Capone? Tax fraud.
Do you know how local, state, and federal governments might eventually be forced to disclose The Public Duty Doctrine, this most vital of information, to the public? Through the Almighty Dollar. Tie mandatory disclosure of The Public Duty Doctrine to annual law enforcement budgets.
Thursday, March 4, 2010
The Public Duty Doctrine.76: Dr. Phil
Dr. Phil's show today was entitled "What's Wrong With People?"
One of the segments involved airing the brutal beating of a girl, Aiesha Steward-Baker, at a Seattle bus terminal in front of security staff. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5vU81qkuvcU
Dr. Phil stated that Aiesha had actually approached Seattle police first and was told to move on.
Nancy Grace, a former Atlanta district attorney and guest on the show today, commented on the attack.
However, neither Dr. Phil nor Nancy Grace mentioned The Public Duty Doctrine, either specifically or generally.
One of the segments involved airing the brutal beating of a girl, Aiesha Steward-Baker, at a Seattle bus terminal in front of security staff. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5vU81qkuvcU
Dr. Phil stated that Aiesha had actually approached Seattle police first and was told to move on.
Nancy Grace, a former Atlanta district attorney and guest on the show today, commented on the attack.
However, neither Dr. Phil nor Nancy Grace mentioned The Public Duty Doctrine, either specifically or generally.
Wednesday, March 3, 2010
The Public Duty Doctrine.75: Sleeping Beauty
The Arts & Leisure section of Sunday's New York Times (2-28-10) ran an article entitled "Violence That Art Didn't See Coming," by Sam Tanenhaus. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/28/arts/28bishop.html
His message: Novelists and Hollywood writers dropped the ball in predicting, through their art, the kind of violence demonstrated by Amy Bishop, "... the neuroscientist arrested for shooting six colleagues, killing three, at a department meeting at the University of Alabama in Huntsville."
Tanenhaus states, "Rampages of this sort have become familiar. But with rare exceptions they have been the preserve of men: lonely, alienated psycho killers with arsenals of high-powered weapons and feverishly composed manifestos." "... the culture is still relatively unprepared for a female killer of the kind suggested by the case of Amy Bishop..."
In a much broader sense, beyond the particulars of the Amy Bishop case, I believe that novelists and Hollywood writers, through a conspiracy of silence, have failed to portray the plight of women in our violent culture. The concept of The Public Duty Doctrine, specifically or generally, is, and has been, conspicuously absent in their writings. The above article should have been entitled, "Violence That Art Turned Its Back On."
John Grisham, Dick Wolf, Jerry Bruckheimer, are you listening?
When a woman calls 9-1-1 or gets a restraining order, does she know that government and its agents (police, district attorneys) have no legal duty to protect; they cannot be held liable for failing to protect because there was no legal duty to protect in the first place?
Women have been betrayed by the criminal justice system and the Arts (writers and producers, like Grisham, Wolf, Bruckheimer).
If I were among those purveyors of lies, I would be afraid -- oh, so afraid -- when the slumbering feminine awakes.
His message: Novelists and Hollywood writers dropped the ball in predicting, through their art, the kind of violence demonstrated by Amy Bishop, "... the neuroscientist arrested for shooting six colleagues, killing three, at a department meeting at the University of Alabama in Huntsville."
Tanenhaus states, "Rampages of this sort have become familiar. But with rare exceptions they have been the preserve of men: lonely, alienated psycho killers with arsenals of high-powered weapons and feverishly composed manifestos." "... the culture is still relatively unprepared for a female killer of the kind suggested by the case of Amy Bishop..."
In a much broader sense, beyond the particulars of the Amy Bishop case, I believe that novelists and Hollywood writers, through a conspiracy of silence, have failed to portray the plight of women in our violent culture. The concept of The Public Duty Doctrine, specifically or generally, is, and has been, conspicuously absent in their writings. The above article should have been entitled, "Violence That Art Turned Its Back On."
John Grisham, Dick Wolf, Jerry Bruckheimer, are you listening?
When a woman calls 9-1-1 or gets a restraining order, does she know that government and its agents (police, district attorneys) have no legal duty to protect; they cannot be held liable for failing to protect because there was no legal duty to protect in the first place?
Women have been betrayed by the criminal justice system and the Arts (writers and producers, like Grisham, Wolf, Bruckheimer).
If I were among those purveyors of lies, I would be afraid -- oh, so afraid -- when the slumbering feminine awakes.
Monday, March 1, 2010
PDD.74: Chicago Gun Law before Court
Here we go again. Will the Supreme Court have the courage to disclose The Public Duty Doctrine as the reason for law-abiding citizens to purchase and own handguns for their own safety?
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/35649914/ns/us_news-crime_and_courts/
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/35649914/ns/us_news-crime_and_courts/
Tuesday, February 23, 2010
PDD.73: Window Dressing From The Right
Proposal to create a National Urban Crime Awareness Week. http://www.gop.gov/bill/111/2/hconres227
Postscript: It failed to pass because there was not a quorum, maybe a lack of interest. It will be put to a vote when a quorum is present -- maybe.
Postscript: It failed to pass because there was not a quorum, maybe a lack of interest. It will be put to a vote when a quorum is present -- maybe.
Saturday, February 20, 2010
The Public Duty Doctrine.72: Cops Don't Co-Parent
C-Span 1 this morning interviewed a Michelle Alexander, author of "The New Jim Crow." The crux of her position was that The Drug War is making people of color, who have been convicted of a felony, permanent second class citizens, a form of branding. She mentioned that America has more people incarcerated than any other country in the world, and that it boils down to racial politics.
I hope this critique clearly presented her basic position.
Question: Why does America have more people incarcerated than any other nation?
Could it be that Ms. Alexander failed to grasp the broad context in which criminal behavior is dealt with?
If the majority of American parents bought into the idea of law enforcement's Protect & Serve motto, could it be that Americans on average, regardless of color, view police paternalistically -- in other words, as co-parents? Co-parenting their unsupervised, out-late-at-night, gang-involved, unprotected-sex-involved, graffiti-involved, drug-involved children?
This view of law enforcement's legal duty (protect & serve) sounds like "It takes a village to raise a child" -- on steroids.
As we know, this is not Mayberry. There is no Sheriff Andy Taylor, who catches a truent student and asks, "Does your momma know where you are?" and then takes him home in the patrol car with a stern warning, released into the arms of an embarrassed mother who says, "Just wait until your father gets home."
No. We're a different kind of America. Law enforcement does not co-parent or enable parents. Their mission, legally speaking, is Law & Order -- period.
Now, here's a twist: Suppose your 14-year-old daughter is raped by a stranger while walking a few blocks from home. She cooperates with the police, goes to the hospital, participates with Rape Crisis counselling, and the case starts to fall apart.
Suppose the father suggests to the investigating officer on more than three occasions that his daughter undergo hypnosis in order to glean more information to help in the investigation.
Suppose the hypnosis is performed with the daughter's and the doctor's agreement. Suppose the father calls the investigating officer upon completion of the hypnosis and says that they'd like to meet at the police station and provide this additional information.
And suppose the next thing that happens is the father receives a letter in the mail from the district attorney's office stating that the father had irreparably harmed his daughter's case by having her memory refreshed; in other words, her memory contaminated by a psychiatrist. Her testimony deemed unreliable by having her memory refreshed.
And at no time did the investigating officer warn the father to refrain from the procedure or to consult an attorney before doing so.
As you can see, cops don't co-parent the parents either.
I hope this critique clearly presented her basic position.
Question: Why does America have more people incarcerated than any other nation?
Could it be that Ms. Alexander failed to grasp the broad context in which criminal behavior is dealt with?
If the majority of American parents bought into the idea of law enforcement's Protect & Serve motto, could it be that Americans on average, regardless of color, view police paternalistically -- in other words, as co-parents? Co-parenting their unsupervised, out-late-at-night, gang-involved, unprotected-sex-involved, graffiti-involved, drug-involved children?
This view of law enforcement's legal duty (protect & serve) sounds like "It takes a village to raise a child" -- on steroids.
As we know, this is not Mayberry. There is no Sheriff Andy Taylor, who catches a truent student and asks, "Does your momma know where you are?" and then takes him home in the patrol car with a stern warning, released into the arms of an embarrassed mother who says, "Just wait until your father gets home."
No. We're a different kind of America. Law enforcement does not co-parent or enable parents. Their mission, legally speaking, is Law & Order -- period.
Now, here's a twist: Suppose your 14-year-old daughter is raped by a stranger while walking a few blocks from home. She cooperates with the police, goes to the hospital, participates with Rape Crisis counselling, and the case starts to fall apart.
Suppose the father suggests to the investigating officer on more than three occasions that his daughter undergo hypnosis in order to glean more information to help in the investigation.
Suppose the hypnosis is performed with the daughter's and the doctor's agreement. Suppose the father calls the investigating officer upon completion of the hypnosis and says that they'd like to meet at the police station and provide this additional information.
And suppose the next thing that happens is the father receives a letter in the mail from the district attorney's office stating that the father had irreparably harmed his daughter's case by having her memory refreshed; in other words, her memory contaminated by a psychiatrist. Her testimony deemed unreliable by having her memory refreshed.
And at no time did the investigating officer warn the father to refrain from the procedure or to consult an attorney before doing so.
As you can see, cops don't co-parent the parents either.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)