Our need to believe in Protect-and-Serve runs deep in our dna. In fact, it goes back thousands of years. This could be why government and its agents fail to disclose The Public Duty Doctrine.
Protect and Serve grew out of Old-World storytelling (as you'll see by the links). In the Old World (Greek), if the hero was about to be killed, a machine-like god would descend and save the hero from certain death. The audience, us, had no problem in believing that we would be saved by some divine being. There was no disgrace in being saved. The gods were always watching and taking sides.
New-World storytelling, however, tells a different tale. In order to be truly victorious, the hero absolutely must resolve his/her complication alone, without the deus ex machina.
These two storytelling methods have been at odds with one another, similar to what I've been talking about with The Public Duty Doctrine versus Protect-and-Serve.
Most of the U.S. population still believes in the Deus ex machina, regarding personal and public safety. They do not want to be told otherwise. However, today's movie audiences want to see the New World hero, not the Old.
Government and its agents are in a pickle. They go along with the charade until they have no choice but to disclose, usually as a result of being sued for failure to protect.
Here's the clincher: Law enforcement wants you to stay in that Old-World frame of mind, wants you to believe in the deus ex machina, and do not want you to aspire to Hollywood's idea of hero problem-solving. If, unfortunately, the deus ex machina fails to snatch you from the jaws of death, how much is an American life worth anyway (See June 18, 2009 posting)?
Welcome to the Old World -- Wanesville.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deus_ex_machina
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/deus%20ex%20machina
Government and its agents (police and district attorneys) have no legal duty to protect; they cannot be held liable for failing to protect. The Problem? They have no legal duty to disclose this. Even worse, there is no evidence that the general population knows of it. See Warren vs. District of Columbia; DeShaney vs. Winnebago County Department of Social Services; Stone vs. N.C. Department of Labor; Castle Rock vs. Gonzales, just to name a few.
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
The Public Duty Doctrine.56: Rapport
One source defines rapport as "close relationship; harmony."
Given the Public Duty Doctrine, law enforcement must rely on the victim-witness-suspect cooperation.
Absent a law enforcement promise to provide Witness Protection, absent a Material Witness Order, cooperation is the only tool left.
The way you get to cooperation, according to law enforcement texts, is: Establish rapport (a close relationship, harmony) with the victim-witness-suspect.
When law enforcement establishes a rapport, say with a victim, it merely reinforces the protect-and-serve propaganda that has been disseminated for so many years.
One of the ways law enforcement gets to rapport is by Mirroring the victim-witness-suspect.
Quoting from "Practical Aspects of Interview and Interrogation," by David E. Zulawski and Douglas E. Wicklander, CRC Press, Inc., 1993, page 143, Mirroring is defined as follows:
"The interviewer who uses only words to build rapport has failed to use all the avenues of communication available. The words spoken between two people account for less than 10% of the communication between individuals. The vast majority of communication takes place using the tone of voice and emphasis on words. In addition, almost half of the communication between individuals is based on physical behavior, posture, and gestures of the participants. Understanding other levels of communication enables the interviewer to incorporate the tone of voice, word emphasis, and physical behavior in his attempt to generate rapport.
"By recognizing the fact that people like people who look, talk, and act similar to themselves, the interviewer can consciously begin to model the speech patterns, speed of delivery, breathing, posture, and the gestures of the individual he is speaking to. This is called mirroring."
Again, when law enforcement establishes a rapport by mirroring, say with a victim-witness, it merely reinforces, in the victim-witness' mind, the protect-and-serve propaganda that is currently in use.
Failing to disclose The Public Duty Doctrine in a timely manner to victim-witnesses is equivalent to a Confidence Game.
I can hear it now. "But, Dave, this is the best system we've got. Nobody's perfect. What you're proposing is so out of touch with the Real World." When I've told people about this, their comeback ( 9 out of 10 times) is: "That would make this place the Wild-Wild West."
When I was little, I believed in Superman, the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy, and Santa Claus. As I grew into adulthood, I thought most, if not all, of the fairytales were gone. For the past 20 years, I have been battling the fairytale of Protect-and-Serve.
If you're comfortable in believing in it, Swim at your own risk.
Given the Public Duty Doctrine, law enforcement must rely on the victim-witness-suspect cooperation.
Absent a law enforcement promise to provide Witness Protection, absent a Material Witness Order, cooperation is the only tool left.
The way you get to cooperation, according to law enforcement texts, is: Establish rapport (a close relationship, harmony) with the victim-witness-suspect.
When law enforcement establishes a rapport, say with a victim, it merely reinforces the protect-and-serve propaganda that has been disseminated for so many years.
One of the ways law enforcement gets to rapport is by Mirroring the victim-witness-suspect.
Quoting from "Practical Aspects of Interview and Interrogation," by David E. Zulawski and Douglas E. Wicklander, CRC Press, Inc., 1993, page 143, Mirroring is defined as follows:
"The interviewer who uses only words to build rapport has failed to use all the avenues of communication available. The words spoken between two people account for less than 10% of the communication between individuals. The vast majority of communication takes place using the tone of voice and emphasis on words. In addition, almost half of the communication between individuals is based on physical behavior, posture, and gestures of the participants. Understanding other levels of communication enables the interviewer to incorporate the tone of voice, word emphasis, and physical behavior in his attempt to generate rapport.
"By recognizing the fact that people like people who look, talk, and act similar to themselves, the interviewer can consciously begin to model the speech patterns, speed of delivery, breathing, posture, and the gestures of the individual he is speaking to. This is called mirroring."
Again, when law enforcement establishes a rapport by mirroring, say with a victim-witness, it merely reinforces, in the victim-witness' mind, the protect-and-serve propaganda that is currently in use.
Failing to disclose The Public Duty Doctrine in a timely manner to victim-witnesses is equivalent to a Confidence Game.
I can hear it now. "But, Dave, this is the best system we've got. Nobody's perfect. What you're proposing is so out of touch with the Real World." When I've told people about this, their comeback ( 9 out of 10 times) is: "That would make this place the Wild-Wild West."
When I was little, I believed in Superman, the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy, and Santa Claus. As I grew into adulthood, I thought most, if not all, of the fairytales were gone. For the past 20 years, I have been battling the fairytale of Protect-and-Serve.
If you're comfortable in believing in it, Swim at your own risk.
Tuesday, December 15, 2009
The Public Duty Doctrine.55: Define Doctrine
As per Wikipedia, the definition of "Doctrine" is as follows: Doctrine (latin doctrina) is a codification of beliefs or "a body of teachings" or "instructions," taught principles or positions, as a body of teachings in a branch of knowledge or belief system.
Taught? To whom?
I could stand outside of any Wal-Mart in the U.S. and ask each person I meet if they know of The Public Duty Doctrine. I could ask a thousand people. Do you have any idea how many of that thousand would know? This doctrine has to do with the "public." This is the most important law concerning the public.
And that's all I have to say about that -- at least, for now.
Taught? To whom?
I could stand outside of any Wal-Mart in the U.S. and ask each person I meet if they know of The Public Duty Doctrine. I could ask a thousand people. Do you have any idea how many of that thousand would know? This doctrine has to do with the "public." This is the most important law concerning the public.
And that's all I have to say about that -- at least, for now.
Monday, December 14, 2009
PDD.53: Prosecutorial Discretion
Here again, like police officers, prosecutors have extraordinary powers. Should your case rest solely on how the prosecutor slept last night?
The upside of this is: You now know you're on your own, at the mercy of so many subjective elements.
http://law.jrank.org/pages/1870/Prosecution-Prosecutorial-Discretion.html
The upside of this is: You now know you're on your own, at the mercy of so many subjective elements.
http://law.jrank.org/pages/1870/Prosecution-Prosecutorial-Discretion.html
The Public Duty Doctrine.52: Police Discretion
The linked article states that police discretion is the "cornerstone of our judicial system."
http://nems360.com/pages/full_story/push?article-police+discretion+called+%E2%80%98cornerstone+of+justice+system%E2%80%99%20&id=3662000-Police+di
So......if government and its agents (police) have no legal duty to protect (The Public Duty Doctrine); they cannot be held legally liable for failing to protect, because there was no legal duty to protect in the first place, then the officer decides (discretion) whether your case/call (9-1-1) has merit or not. This is an extraordinary power. The public must understand their relationship with the criminal justice system.
A 2003, college textbook, entitled "Criminology," authored by Larry J. Siegel, page 499, states, "Police discretion involves the selective enforcement of the law by duly authorized police agents. However, unlike members of almost every other criminal justice agency, police officers are neither regulated in their daily procedures by administrative scrutiny nor subjected to judicial review (except when their behavior clearly violates an offender's constitutional rights). As a result, the exercise of discretion by police may sometimes deteriorate into discrimination, violence, and other abusive practices."
If it all boils down to how that officer (responding to your call) feels, we're in trouble.
Welcome to Wanesville!!!!!!!
http://nems360.com/pages/full_story/push?article-police+discretion+called+%E2%80%98cornerstone+of+justice+system%E2%80%99%20&id=3662000-Police+di
So......if government and its agents (police) have no legal duty to protect (The Public Duty Doctrine); they cannot be held legally liable for failing to protect, because there was no legal duty to protect in the first place, then the officer decides (discretion) whether your case/call (9-1-1) has merit or not. This is an extraordinary power. The public must understand their relationship with the criminal justice system.
A 2003, college textbook, entitled "Criminology," authored by Larry J. Siegel, page 499, states, "Police discretion involves the selective enforcement of the law by duly authorized police agents. However, unlike members of almost every other criminal justice agency, police officers are neither regulated in their daily procedures by administrative scrutiny nor subjected to judicial review (except when their behavior clearly violates an offender's constitutional rights). As a result, the exercise of discretion by police may sometimes deteriorate into discrimination, violence, and other abusive practices."
If it all boils down to how that officer (responding to your call) feels, we're in trouble.
Welcome to Wanesville!!!!!!!
Saturday, December 12, 2009
The Public Duty Doctrine.51: Fire Department
The author of this article, Vincent Brannigan, writes, in paragraph five, "Given the supposed litigious nature of American society...."
The reason they are litigious is because they have no idea of the Public Duty Doctrine. The bought into the idea of "Protect and Serve."
http://firechief.com/leadership/management-administration/firefighting_duty_debate_marches/
The reason they are litigious is because they have no idea of the Public Duty Doctrine. The bought into the idea of "Protect and Serve."
http://firechief.com/leadership/management-administration/firefighting_duty_debate_marches/
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)